Moshe halbertal vividly describes maimonidess childhood in muslim spain, his. The meiri reformulated the conception of idolatry, contending that it had disappeared from everywhere except the extremities of civilization. The idea and practice of sacrifice play a profound role in religion, ethics, and politics. Pdf theology, ethnography, and the historicization of idolatry. The ethical demand of the book is that a selfsacrifice for another individual, value, or collective seems key to much of ethical life. Moshe halbertal is a noted israeli philosopher, professor, and writer, and a noted expert on. Despite the momentous implications of such a turn, the role of idolatry in giving it direction and impetus is little understood. Pdf theology, ethnography, and the historicization of. Moore, this account of a subject central to our culture also has much to say about metaphor, myth, and the application of philosophical analysis to religious concepts and sensibilities.
Idolatry by moshe halbertal, avishai margalit waterstones. He is the author of people of the book and the coauthor with avishai margalit of idolatry. Read bullet journal carnet pointille a5 pour prendre des notes lettrage calligraphie gribouiller serie design kawaii french edition prime publishing 9781799187165 books. Moshe halbertal, gruss professor of law at new york university school of law and professor of jewish thought and philosophy at hebrew university of jerusalem, gave. Moshe idel, hebrew university the discussion throughout is of a very high order the outstanding contribution of the book is that it both defines and helps to solve the difficulties surrounding the notion of idolatry on one hand, while using this discussion to shed light on the multiple developments of the notion throughout our. Esotericism in jewish thought and its philosophical implications both princeton. Reliable information about the coronavirus covid19 is available from the world health organization current situation, international travel. Theology, ethnography, and the historicization of idolatry article pdf available in journal of the history of ideas 674. Halbertal suggests that maimonidess true position is the radical one he conveys to his close disciples, but that as the master of concealment and. This injunction, handed down through moses three thousand years ago, marks one of the most decisive shifts in western culture. This product is currently unavailable this product is currently unavailable.
He is the author of the books idolatry coauthored with avishai margalit, and people of the book. Within the marriage metaphor god is the jealous and betrayed husband, israel is the unfaithful wife, and the third parties in the. Halbertal also claims that in our modern world, chesed is going beyond the self. Born in andalusia near the tail end of the centurieslong flourishing of spanish jewry, and expelled from spain by its harsh muslim rulers, the almohids, he fled with his family to morocco.
Idolatry moshe halbertal and avishai margalit cambridge, ma. Aug 05, 2012 lecture on three concepts of faith by moshe halbertal, on july 2, 2012, to the 2012 rabbinical torah study summer retreat in jerusalem, israel. Moshe halbertal and stephen holmes show how the beautifully crafted narratives of saul and david cut to the core of politics, exploring themes that resonate wherever political power is at stake. The rise of the bibles negative attitude toward the golden calf new. Lecture on three concepts of faith by moshe halbertal, on july 2, 2012, to the 2012 rabbinical torah study summer retreat in jerusalem, israel. Moshe halbertal and avishai margalit, idolatry cambridge, ma. Moshe halbertals maimonides is a useful guide to the man and his work, with something to offer both novice and scholar. Idolatry by moshe halbertal, avishai margalit, naomi.
Ranging with authority from the talmud to maimonides, from marx to nietzsche and on to g. Through the root metaphor of marriage, gods relationship to israel is construed by the prophets as exclusive. He draws on maimonidess letters and the testimonies of his contemporaries, both muslims and jews, to offer new insights into his personality and the circumstances that. Avishai margalit you shall have no other gods besides me. In their excellent study idolatry, moshe halbertal and avishai margalit argue that there are three distinctly modern forms of discourse on idolatry, what they call replacement, extension, and inversion these arguments are detailed below. However, the practice of idolatry is what extends further. Oclcs webjunction has pulled together information and resources to assist library staff as they consider how to handle coronavirus. Mark blitz, weekly standard in a sea of literature about the great twelfthcentury jewish sage and philosopher, one could do no better than turn to moshe halbertals single volume. Idolatry, coauthored with avishai margalit, translated by naomi goldblum harvard.
In these monotheistic religions, idolatry has been considered as the worship of false gods and is forbidden by the values. Jerome eckstein, moshe halbertal and avishai margalit. He draws on maimonidess letters and the testimonies of his contemporaries, both muslims and jews, to offer. Moshe halbertal is professor of philosophy at the hebrew university of jerusalem, a fellow at the shalom hartman institute, and the gruss professor at new york university law school. Numerous and frequentlyupdated resource results are available from this search. However, there are other forms of idolatry that are also addressed in the bible. For more on these two views of idolatry, see haym soloveitchik, collected essays. Idolatry edition 1 by moshe halbertal, avishai margalit. Pdf moshe halbertal and avishai margalit, idolatry cambridge. War against the idols download ebook pdf, epub, tuebl, mobi.
In rare instances, a publisher has elected to have a zero moving wall, so their current issues are available. Calling attention to the importance of the idolatry issue during the reformation, this study traces the development of protestant iconoclastic theology and practice and lays a foundation for understanding the conflicting reformed ideology. Moshe halbertal has a tremendous knack for turning arcane topics and esoteric texts into the most exciting and topical ideas to think about. Halbertal, moshe the idea and practice of sacrifice play a profound role in religion, ethics, and politics. Idolatry is the worship of an idol or image, being a picture, a statue, or a person in place of god. Through stories such as sauls madness, davids murder of uriah, the rape of tamar, and the rebellion of absalom, the books author deepens our.
Life and thought, by moshe halbertal maimonides was the greatest jewish philosopher and legal scholar of the medieval period, a towering figure who has had a profound and lasting influence on jewish law, philosophy, and religious consciousness. Moshe halbertal avishai margalit translated by naomi goldblum. Jun 02, 2015 moshe halbertal vividly describes maimonidess childhood in muslim spain, his familys flight to north africa to escape persecution, and their eventual resettling in egypt. Moshe halbertal vividly describes maimonidess childhood in muslim spain, his familys flight to north africa to escape persecution, and their eventual resettling in egypt. Click download or read online button to get war against the idols book now. Reason, revelation, and jewish thought july 28, 2014. Avishai margalit is schulman professor emeritus of philosophy at the hebrew university of jerusalem and a former george f.
Moshe halbertal argues that selftranscendence is at. Idolatry moshe halbertal, avishai margalit harvard. Even though, as halbertal and margalit note, the central theological principle in the bible is the refutation of idolatry 10,1 it is ironic that the category that is supposed to be the firmest and strictest of all. He is a coauthor of the israeli army code of ethics. The moving wall represents the time period between the last issue available in jstor and the most recently published issue of a journal. The book is at its most profound in sorting out the relation between violence and sacrifice. Several other studies have been similarly useful, including joel marcus, idolatry in the new testament, interpretation 60, no. Moshe halbertal is the gruss professor of law at new york university, professor of jewish thought and philosophy at the hebrew university, and professor of law at idc herzliya in israel. Still today, many around the world bow down before various idols. Concealment and revelation princeton university press.
This site is like a library, use search box in the widget to get ebook that you want. In their excellent study idolatry, moshe halbertal and avishai margalit argue that there are three distinctly modern forms of discourse on idolatry, what they call replacement,extension, and inversion these arguments aredetailed below. Mar 18, 2019 idolatry moshe halbertal avishai margalit naomi goldblum books download as pdf. There are no obvious signs of damage on the item or its cover. Rosenzweigs notion of idolatry cannot be assimilated under any of these three categories, although. He received his phd from hebrew university in 1989, and from 1988 to 1992 he was a fellow at the society of fellows at harvard university. The concept of idolatry in the bible is powerful and complex, diverse and problematic. Jul 03, 2014 halbertal distinguishes in chapter 4 between a moderate and radical reading of mt. Moshe halbertal halbertal presents a moving and detailed portrait of maimonidess life as well as his work. In this brief book, philosopher moshe halbertal explores the meaning and implications of sacrifice, developing a theory of sacrifice as an offering and examining the relationship between sacrifice, ritual, violence, and love. Idolatry moshe halbertal, avishai margalit harvard university. Moshe halbertal, stephen holmes new insights into how the book of samuel offers a timeless meditation on the dilemmas of statecraft the book of samuel is universally acknowledged as one of the supreme achievements of biblical literature. Moshe halbertal teaches jewish thought and philosophy at the hebrew university of jerusalem.
Moshe halbertal teaches jewish thought and philosophy at the hebrew. In addition it is forbidden to derive benefit hanaah from anything dedicated to idolatry. Idolatry simple english wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. In judaism, christianity and islam, idolatry means worshiping something that is not god. Moshe halbertal has also served as a visiting professor at harvard law school, and at the university of pennsylvania law school.
Kennan professor at the institute for advanced study, princeton. Moshe halbertal and avishai margalit, idolatry, trans. Moshe halbertal is the gruss professor of law at nyu school of law, the john and golda cohen professor of jewish thought and philosophy at the hebrew university and a professor of law at idc. Idolatry moshe halbertal avishai margalit naomi goldblum. It is forbidden by religious rules such as the ten commandments.
In abrahamic religions, namely christianity, islam and judaism, idolatry connotes the worship of something or someone other than god as if it were god. Idolatry by moshe halbertal, avishai margalit, naomi goldblum. His books include on sacrifice and concealment and revelation. Idolatry moshe halbertal avishai margalit naomi goldblum books download as pdf. On sacrifice moves from biblical practices of animal sacrifice to modern ideas about selfsacrifice in war. He took the babylonian talmud and the body of subsequent traditions and created essentially a practical, categorized moral and legal handbook, the mishneh torah, separating core teachings from doubtful. Canon, meaning, and authority, both published by harvard university press. Click and collect from your local waterstones or get free uk delivery on orders over. Buy idolatry by moshe halbertal, avishai margalit from waterstones today. Even though, as halbertal and margalit note, the central theological principle in the bible is the refutation of idolatry 10, 1 it is ironic that the category that is supposed to be the firmest and strictest of allexhibits an astonishing fluidity 250 2. Publication date 1992 topics idolatry publisher harvard university press. Rosenzweigs notion of idolatry cannot be assimilated under any of these three.
Soloveitchik uses the terms credal and cultic on pp. Idolatry 2 written together with hebrew university philosopher avishai margalit. Moshe halbertal moshe halbertal is the gruss professor at nyu law school and professor of jewish thought and philosophy at the hebrew university, and a fellow at the shalom hartman institute. Halbertal, moshe, goldblum, naomi, margalit, avishai. Moshe halbertal is the gruss professor of law at nyu school of. However, aniconism in judaism has not prevented traditions of jewish art at various periods.
Halbertal distinguishes in chapter 4 between a moderate and radical reading of mt. Judaism holds that idolatry is not limited to the worship of an idol itself, but also worship involving any artistic representations of god. Idolatry has traditionally been associated with the worship of physical idols, gods and goddesses in the form of statues made by human hands. Moshe halbertal argues that selftranscendence is at the core of human capacity for moral life. Reason, revelation, and jewish thought july 28, 2014 august.
Menachem hameiri approach to understanding to talmudic restrictions on interaction with gentiles. This admirable work invites us to study moses maimonides writings on our own. The prohibitions against idolatry are an attempt to dictate the ways in which god. However, formatting rules can vary widely between applications and fields of interest or study. May 30, 2012 halbertal also claims that in our modern world, chesed is going beyond the self. Moshe halbertal on sacrifice the book of doctrines and.
298 1462 1451 540 278 579 320 1355 475 237 62 723 775 751 1308 956 313 1040 719 902 1366 268 504 1020 610 328 1303 408 923 279 853 733 985 434